top of page
Oct 17
7 min read


Spellcast by Sophie Jordan | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson
Spellcast by Sophie Jordan | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson

I thoroughly enjoyed A Fire in the Sky and A Scar in the Bone, so picking up Spellcast felt like returning to a world I was already rather fond of. Sophie Jordan had given me two books that reminded me just how entertaining romantasy can be when the characters, magic and romance come together. I was genuinely looking forward to another visit. Unfortunately, this third instalment was a rather disappointing experience, and I finished it wondering what had happened to the storytelling that made the previous two books so enjoyable.


The premise certainly wasn't the problem. Arden has spent ten years under a curse that has rendered her invisible to everyone around her. Unable to speak to her family or make herself known, she's been forced to watch life continue without her, including the grief of those who believe she's disappeared. When her village is destroyed by fire, she encounters a group of dragon shifters who, remarkably, can see her. Among them is Tage, their imposing alpha, who promptly takes her captive and introduces her to an entirely different existence.


I thought the idea of a young woman spending a decade completely unseen was fascinating. Imagine being present for every family conversation, every celebration and every tragedy, yet having absolutely no way of participating. There's something genuinely heartbreaking about that, particularly when Arden must watch the people she loves mourn her while she's standing right there. Jordan gives us glimpses of the emotional toll this takes, and initially I was quite invested in Arden's predicament.


The trouble is that we spend an awfully long time establishing just how miserable her existence has become. I understood the loneliness and despair well before the narrative was ready to move forward. Eventually, the repetition began to wear on me, and I found myself becoming impatient for something to happen. I don't mind a slow beginning, especially when there's worthwhile character development taking place, but I do want to feel that the story is progressing. Here, it seemed to linger over the same emotional territory without adding a great deal to my understanding of Arden.


And then, when the dragons finally arrive, everything changes rather abruptly.


Suddenly there's a new world to understand, a mysterious curse to unravel, magical abilities to discover, political tensions brewing and, of course, a romance to develop. It's quite a lot to squeeze into the remaining pages, particularly after such a leisurely beginning. I found the pacing rather frustrating because the elements I most wanted to know more about were precisely those that seemed to receive the least attention.


Tage didn't particularly help matters. I generally have no objection to a brooding, possessive dragon shifter. They're practically part of the furniture in romantasy, and when written well they can be enormous fun. Unfortunately, I struggled to see much beyond Tage's dominance and physical attraction to Arden. His controlling behaviour is clearly intended to contribute to the romantic tension, but I wanted more of a personality and considerably more emotional development before I could become invested in their relationship.


What bothered me most was how quickly Arden's relationship with Tage became defined by sexual attraction. After ten years of isolation, surely the experience of being seen, heard and touched again would be almost overwhelming. There was so much opportunity to consider how that deprivation might affect Arden's ability to trust someone, establish boundaries or even understand what she wanted from a relationship. Instead, the romance seemed far more interested in the physical chemistry between them.


And yes, there's plenty of spice. I'm certainly not opposed to explicit romance, but I prefer it when the intimacy grows naturally from the characters and their developing connection. Here, I wasn't particularly convinced by the emotional foundations of the relationship, so the increasingly steamy encounters did very little to improve my enthusiasm. I wanted to believe that Arden and Tage were falling in love rather than simply being irresistibly attracted to one another.


I also found myself questioning the treatment of Arden's independence. Her original predicament arises from a desperate desire to escape the restrictions imposed by her father, yet when she finally encounters people capable of seeing her, she's promptly taken captive by another powerful man. There's an interesting parallel there, and I would have liked Sophiw to do much more with it. Arden has spent ten years without any meaningful control over her life. Watching her recover that independence should have been one of the most satisfying parts of the story. Instead, her freedom sometimes felt secondary to Tage's possessiveness.


The worldbuilding was another disappointment. I enjoyed the dragons and the wider mythology established in the previous books, and I was hoping this instalment would add something substantial to that world. Witches, ancient magic, dragon shifters and the threat of war should have provided plenty of material to work with, but I never felt particularly immersed in the politics or magical systems. There were interesting ideas scattered throughout the narrative, yet too many seemed to be introduced without being developed sufficiently. I wanted to understand more about the dragons themselves, their society and the wider consequences of the magical revelations.


By the final chapters, I was feeling rather detached from the outcome. The story gathers speed, explanations arrive and conflicts move towards resolution, but after so much time spent establishing Arden's circumstances, I wanted a more substantial emotional payoff. Her curse has cost her an entire decade of life, and that deserves more than a convenient resolution to the supernatural mystery. I wanted to feel the significance of what she'd endured and what reclaiming her place in the world might actually mean for her.




It's also worth mentioning that this is a darker story than its romantic elements might suggest. Arden's prolonged isolation and despair are central to the novel, and there's significant grief and loss surrounding the destruction of her village. Readers should also be aware of violence, death, captivity, controlling relationship dynamics and explicit sexual content. There have additionally been reader reports of child death and brief suicidal thoughts. These subjects aren't necessarily reasons to avoid a book, but I think readers deserve to know what they're likely to encounter, particularly when the emotional suffering is such a prominent part of the narrative.




I suspect much of my disappointment comes from how much I enjoyed the first two books. I know Sophie is capable of creating compelling romantic tension and an engaging fantasy world because I've already experienced it. I had every reason to think Spellcast would deliver another enjoyable instalment, and I don't think my expectations were unreasonable. I was perfectly happy to embrace the dragons, the magic and even the rather overbearing alpha male, provided there was enough substance behind them.


There were still aspects I appreciated. Arden's situation is genuinely intriguing, the opening establishes a convincing sense of loneliness, and I liked the idea that the very creatures she has reason to fear are the ones capable of acknowledging her existence. I could see the ingredients of a much stronger story throughout. That probably made the disappointment worse, because I kept recognising opportunities for emotional depth or greater complexity that never quite materialised.


Two stars might seem a little harsh given how much I loved the previous instalments, but I rate each book on its own merits. Spellcast has an imaginative foundation, yet I found the pacing uneven, the romance unconvincing and the wider fantasy elements insufficiently developed. By the time I reached the ending, I was relieved to have finished rather than sorry to be leaving the characters behind.


I'll certainly read Sophie Jordan again. Two thoroughly enjoyable books have earned her that much goodwill from me. I just wish Spellcast had given me a little more to love, because I really did want to enjoy this one.



🔎 Read this if you enjoy dragon romantasy with curses, hidden magic and forbidden attraction

📚 Third instalment in Sophie Jordan’s A Fire in the Sky series

💭 Dragon shifters, witches, magical secrets and supernatural powers

👥 Forced proximity, enemies to lovers, possessive alpha male and steamy romance

🌿 Identity, isolation, freedom, belonging and reclaiming personal power

⚠️ Includes violence, death, grief, prolonged emotional isolation, captivity, coercive behaviour and explicit sexual content. Reader reports also mention child death and brief suicidal thoughts.













Book Details

Spellcast by Sophie Jordan

Paperback ISBN

978-0008789626 — HQ / HarperCollins trade paperback edition published in Australia on 28 July 2026.

Hardcover ISBN

978-0008789565 — HQ / HarperCollins limited collector's hardcover edition listed for Australian publication on 27 October 2026.

eBook ISBN

978-0008789633 — HQ / HarperCollins English-language digital edition published on 28 July 2026.

Audiobook ISBN

978-0008789640 — HQ / HarperCollins unabridged English-language digital audiobook published on 28 July 2026.

Genre

Fantasy Romance; Romantasy; Paranormal Romance; Epic Fantasy; Romantic Fantasy; Adult Fantasy; Adventure Fiction.

Subgenre

Dragon-Shifter Romance; High Fantasy Romance; Witchcraft Fantasy; Supernatural Romance; Magical Curse Fantasy; Dark Romantic Fantasy; Epic Romantic Adventure.

Tropes / Literary Threads

Cursed heroine; magical invisibility; dragon shifters; possessive alpha male; captor-captive romance; forced proximity; enemies to lovers; forbidden attraction; touch her and die; hidden magical powers; magical awakening; witches and curses; revenge; ancient magic

Publisher

HQ / HarperCollins Publishers — Australian paperback, limited hardcover, eBook and audiobook editions.

Series

A Fire in the Sky — Book 3. Follows A Fire in the Sky (Book 1) and A Scar in the Bone (Book 2). Marketed as a standalone romantasy set within the same fantasy world, featuring new central protagonists.

Formats Available

Trade paperback; hardcover; limited collector's hardcover; Kindle eBook; unabridged digital audiobook.

Audiobook Narrator

Fiona Hardingham.

Audiobook Length

11 hours and 17 minutes — unabridged English-language audiobook narrated by Fiona Hardingham.

Original Release Date

28 July 2026 — original English-language publication.

Page Count

352 pages — Australian-listed HQ trade paperback ISBN 9780008789626.


Where to Buy Spellcast by Sophie Jordan

📚 Amazon


Affiliate Disclosure

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my Amazon affiliate links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I also encourage supporting Australian booksellers such as QBD Books, independent booksellers, and self-published authors whenever possible.


Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker
Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker

Danielle Robinson is a literary critic and writer whose work explores literature through the

lens of atmosphere, memory, culture, and emotional experience.


Holding a double degree in philosophy and theology, she combines academic insight with a deeply refined aesthetic sensibility shaped by more than three decades working across the creative industries as an internationally published, multi-award-winning makeup artist, fashion stylist, and interior stager.


She reads widely and rigorously, reading and reviewing more than 200 books each year as both an ARC reader and commissioned critic. Through Silk & Sentences, Danielle approaches literature as something immersive and lived with — not simply stories to consume, but works that shape the way we think, feel, and move through the world.


She writes from her semi-rural Queensland home, where she lives with Alex, her husband of 33 years, their dogs Oscar and Paige, and an ever-growing library of books.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page