top of page
11 hours ago
6 min read
The Knave & the Moon by Rachel Gillig | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson
The Knave & the Moon by Rachel Gillig | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson

I’d give Bartholomew his own shelf if I could persuade him to stay on it. He’s a bat-shaped gargoyle with a peculiar way of putting a sentence together, but when Rachel Gillig wants to say something serious about grief or memory, he’s the character I most want to hear from. That’s a large part of why The Knave and the Moon is a Milky Way book for me. I’ll keep both volumes and reread them together. I want to see how early Gillig set up the things that moved me most, back when I was still getting my bearings at Aisling Cathedral.


What is The Knave and the Moon about?


Aisling Cathedral has fallen, and King Benji is using his marriage to Sybil Delling, the last Diviner, to shore up his authority. His wedding celebrations take the form of tournaments across the kingdom. Then a stranger with no name and no memory enters the competition, and Benji has to contend with the possibility that the crowds he’s gathered might cheer for someone else.


What I loved about it


One of the pleasures of Gillig’s prose is how much of the book I can hear. Benji speaks for an audience even when he’s in a room with someone who used to be his friend. Bartholomew addresses practically everybody as Bartholomew and can make a perfectly ordinary exchange take a turn I couldn’t have predicted. His sentences are funny because they follow his thinking so faithfully. Over time, that funny little habit of naming everyone alike comes to feel generous. I like that Gillig trusts a joke to gather meaning over two books. It still makes me laugh when I know where she’s going with it.


There’s a lot of love for Rory in the five-star reviews, and I’m with those readers, especially on the question of his memory. Minor spoiler for the early tournaments. Gillig gives it back to him early enough to get to the part I find much more interesting. He remembers Sybil and has to let Benji think he doesn’t. There’s a marvellous scene in which Sybil performs a Divination on Rory in front of the king. Benji thinks he’s watching his captive queen carry out a ritual. Sybil's finding out whether the man in front of her knows her. Gillig gets more intimacy out of that exchange than she could have had the two of them been given a whole evening alone. Having Rory’s point of view this time adds to the pleasure. I can see what it costs him to hold back, and I appreciate the care he takes to give Sybil a choice when nearly every other person in her life has claimed the right to decide for her.


The tournament is where the medieval adventure and the political story really come together for me. Benji thinks he can travel from hamlet to hamlet and show everyone what a splendid king they have. Then Maude wins her joust against him and rides straight into the royal viewing box. I love the nerve of that scene. She creates enough confusion to give Sybil a chance to act, and the king himself has supplied the crowd. The same instinct drives the more unsettling gothic passages. Gillig is interested in what happens when a ruler or a church can decide what an audience is allowed to see and what that spectacle is supposed to mean.


I can see why some readers wanted more of the boy Benji used to be. I felt that most keenly when Sybil has a chance to hurt him early on and his frightened expression reminds her of the friend she knew. It’s uncomfortable to remember someone with affection when you have every reason to despise what they’ve done, and I liked Gillig allowing Sybil that discomfort. She gives Sybil an even harder reckoning with her own future. After years of being valued for what her body can do for others, Sybil has come to believe that taking herself out of the king’s reach might require sacrificing her life. There’s a great deal of tenderness in the way her friends take that despair seriously. The romance has room for desire, but the quieter kindnesses are what made me believe in the future Gillig was asking me to want for her.


Questions about The Knave and the Moon


Do I need to read The Knight and the Moth first?

Yes. The friendship and betrayal at the end of The Knight and the Moth shape almost every decision in this book. I’d buy or borrow them together if you’re starting fresh. Gillig has described the duology as one continuous story with a painful cliffhanger, and that’s exactly how the two books feel in the reading. Rachel Gillig’s interview with On the Same Page


How dark is it, and how much romance is there?

There’s a proper romance here, with banter, yearning and enough time spent in Rory’s head to understand why the smallest gesture between them matters. There’s also coercion, forced marriage, abuse, graphic violence and a sustained thread of suicidal ideation. I’d pay particular attention to that last one if it’s sensitive territory for you. Sybil spends a significant part of the novel believing that her death might be necessary, which gives the book’s eventual hope real weight.


Does the ending pay off? Full spoilers below

For me, the answer is in Sybil’s hammer. She’s spent the book striking people or breaking things charged with stolen power. After Bartholomew dissolves in the spring, she takes that same hammer and uses it to carve him a body. I love how practical this act of devotion is. She has to shape the stone. Gillig has given the woman who expected to die a job that requires her to imagine her friend alive again and do the work to bring him back.


I wanted Maude to have more life, too. The fact that she dies protecting a sprite, when her family made its name killing them, gives her decision a particular force. I still wanted a future for the woman who had the nerve to ride into that viewing box. It matters to me that the epilogue has room for both feelings. A hundred years later, what happened is still being told. The revelation that the Diviners’ visions were the Eternal Moon’s memories makes that act of telling matter. People spent generations looking for a prophecy in what was really somebody’s account of the harm done to her.


And it’s Bartholomew who gets to speak. I think that’s the choice that put this book on my Milky Way shelf. I’d love to go back to the first time he calls somebody by his own name and hear it again with the whole story in mind.


Further reading



Genre

Adult gothic romantasy + dark fantasy + fairy-tale fantasy

















Where to Buy The Knave and the Moon by Rebecca Gillig

📚 Amazon


Affiliate Disclosure

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my Amazon affiliate links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I also encourage supporting Australian booksellers such as QBD Books, independent booksellers, and self-published authors whenever possible.

Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker
Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker

Danielle Robinson is a literary critic and writer whose work explores literature through the

lens of atmosphere, memory, culture, and emotional experience.


Holding a double degree in philosophy and theology, she combines academic insight with a deeply refined aesthetic sensibility shaped by more than three decades working across the creative industries as an internationally published, multi-award-winning makeup artist, fashion stylist, and interior stager.


She reads widely and rigorously, reading and reviewing more than 200 books each year as both an ARC reader and commissioned critic. Through Silk & Sentences, Danielle approaches literature as something immersive and lived with — not simply stories to consume, but works that shape the way we think, feel, and move through the world.


She writes from her semi-rural Queensland home, where she lives with Alex, her husband of 33 years, their dogs Oscar and Paige, and an ever-growing library of books.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page