top of page
3 days ago
5 min read

The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson
The Knight and the Moth by Rachel Gillig | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson

The part I keep coming back to is that Sybil is proud of being a Diviner. She’s good at it, and when one of the other girls has to go into the water, she’ll take her place. I admired that in her before I understood what it was costing her. Rachel Gillig gets an entire gothic novel out of the fact that Sybil’s courage makes her so easy for the abbess to rely on. I've already allocated this book it's own prized placement in my library and ordered the special edition, and want to go back to the cathedral and see what I took on faith the first time.


What is The Knight and the Moth about?

Six foundling girls serve as Diviners at Aisling Cathedral, where they're drowned in a sacred spring so they can dream of the future. Their ten years of service are almost over when five of the women disappear. The remaining Diviner, known as Six, sets out to find them with a group of others including a hilarious gargoyle and a knight called Rodrick Myndacious (Rory), who has very little to say in favour of her religion.


My review

A heroine who keeps her own name secret, a gargoyle who never gets to the point, and a cathedral hiding something worse than either: this book had me hooked.


Sybil’s short straw moves me because it spares someone she loves. Her sisters have built a shared life within the small space they’re allowed, and they plan for the day their service ends. I wanted that ordinary future for them. Gillig shows enough of their bond to make Sybil’s choice to leave everything familiar and search for them believable. Soon I was as anxious for the women as I was curious about the cathedral’s secrets.


Gillig’s cathedral is a joy to read. The gargoyle’s first act is to promise to save a fly from a spider’s web, but he dwells so long on the dangers of flight that Sybil slips away, and I sided with the fly. Her dry affection as she watches him reveals their friendship better than any history of how long they’ve known each other. The prose is just as striking when it turns cold: in the spring, the water turns Sybil’s robe translucent before a crowd that's come to hear what she can tell them. I kept thinking about how little anyone actually sees of her.


Beyond Aisling, the quest reads like an old fairy tale, with five hamlets, enchanted objects, and trials whose clear-sounding rules depend on trusting whoever wrote them. My favourite is the Harried Scribe’s challenge. Everyone expects a test of obscure knowledge, yet what defeats him is Sybil’s name. I admired the nerve of making that the deciding question among all those books. After years of being known as a number, the answer she kept for herself outweighs everything the Scribe has gathered.


That attention to names is part of why the romance worked for me. Sybil calls Rory Myndacious for so long that I began to wonder what she'd call him once she let her guard down. The banter's fun, but I truly warmed to him when he took her ability seriously before a fight she had good reason to fear. After doubting so much that she holds sacred, his belief in her lands with unexpected tenderness. When she trusts him with her name, it was clear how much it meant to share what she could have kept.


I’m fond of Maude too: a woman in her forties who teaches Sybil to fight and notices when she needs care. Maude, Rory and the gargoyle all compete for my affection, but the gargoyle wins. His odd way of telling a story was funny at first, and I expect to linger over those scenes on a reread. By the end, I saw how closely I should have listened to him.


The cliffhanger hurts, and I was glad a second book was waiting. This one earns a Milky Way rating because I’m as keen to reread it as to find out what comes next. I want another evening in Aisling, with the gargoyle struggling to get to the point and Sybil confident she understands the place. I’m now fond enough of them both to know the first chapter will read differently.

 

Questions readers ask about The Knight and the Moth


How much romance is there?

It’s a slow burn with explicit, consensual sex scenes. You’ll spend much of the book with Sybil and Rory trying to work out how much they can trust each other while the search for the Diviners and the quest through Traum drive the action. If the best bit of a romance for you is the accumulation of small changes in how two people speak to each other, there’s a lot to enjoy here.


How dark does it get?

The drownings are repeated and described on the page, including choking and vomiting. They’re the first thing I’d mention to anyone deciding whether to read it. There’s also religious coercion, confinement, child abuse and death, graphic violence, body horror, grief, a brief violent animal death, alcohol and fictional drug use. The humour is one of the reasons I loved the book, and the cathedral scenes can still be hard going. See reader-submitted content warnings on StoryGraph.


Do I need to read One Dark Window first?

You can start here. One Dark Window opens Gillig’s Shepherd King duology. The Knight and the Moth introduces a new world and cast in the Stonewater Kingdom duology, which concludes with The Knave and the Moon.


Does it end on a cliffhanger?

Yes, a substantial one. The search that draws Sybil out of Aisling yields real answers, so there’s plenty to think about at the end of book one. You may still want The Knave and the Moon to hand when you get to those last pages.


Who should pick it up?

Pick it up if you like fairy tales that get a little grisly, romances in which trust builds slowly, and fantasy worlds whose rituals tell you something about the people living under them. Start with the first chapter if you’re on the fence. You’ll know fairly quickly whether you want to spend time with that gargoyle.


Further reading


Genre

Adult gothic romantasy + dark fantasy + fairy-tale fantasy

















Where to Buy The Knight and the Moth by Rebecca Gillig

📚 Amazon


Affiliate Disclosure

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my Amazon affiliate links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I also encourage supporting Australian booksellers such as QBD Books, independent booksellers, and self-published authors whenever possible.

Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker
Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker

Danielle Robinson is a literary critic and writer whose work explores literature through the

lens of atmosphere, memory, culture, and emotional experience.


Holding a double degree in philosophy and theology, she combines academic insight with a deeply refined aesthetic sensibility shaped by more than three decades working across the creative industries as an internationally published, multi-award-winning makeup artist, fashion stylist, and interior stager.


She reads widely and rigorously, reading and reviewing more than 200 books each year as both an ARC reader and commissioned critic. Through Silk & Sentences, Danielle approaches literature as something immersive and lived with — not simply stories to consume, but works that shape the way we think, feel, and move through the world.


She writes from her semi-rural Queensland home, where she lives with Alex, her husband of 33 years, their dogs Oscar and Paige, and an ever-growing library of books.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page