top of page
Oct 20
8 min read


The Score by Elle Kennedy | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson
The Score by Elle Kennedy | Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson

Dean Di-Laurentis is the sort of man who's probably never had to wait for a table in his life. He's beautiful, obscenely wealthy, academically gifted, enormously popular and entirely aware of every one of those advantages. He also has an astonishing capacity for enjoying himself, generally in the company of whichever willing woman happens to catch his attention. Modesty isn't one of his defining characteristics, although I suspect he considers that everyone else's problem.


But, somewhere beneath all that confidence and expensive good fortune, there's a character worth getting to know. That's what kept me interested in The Score, even when I found myself less enthusiastic about the story surrounding him.


This is the third instalment in Elle Kennedy's Off-Campus series, and having given both The Deal and The Mistake four stars, I had good reason to expect another enjoyable romance. Kennedy has a talent for writing friendships that feel lived-in, and the Briar University hockey players have become a group whose ridiculous conversations and irresponsible decisions I'm happy to spend time with.


Dean's been a wonderfully entertaining supporting character in the earlier novels. Giving him an entire book, though, presents Kennedy with an interesting challenge. How do you develop a man whose life appears to have been arranged for his personal convenience, particularly when he doesn't seem all that interested in changing it?


Enter Allie Hayes.


Allie is an aspiring actress emerging from a long and unsatisfactory relationship with Sean, a boyfriend whose expectations about their future have left little room for her own ambitions. She's emotionally exhausted, determined not to become involved with anyone else and understandably wary of Dean's reputation. Unfortunately for her considered intentions, Dean turns out to be difficult to resist.


Their arrangement begins casually, with neither expecting anything resembling a relationship. Naturally, matters become complicated once genuine affection enters the equation.


I liked Allie, especially her determination to pursue an acting career despite the uncertainty that comes with it. Her relationship with Sean has left her questioning whether love requires sacrificing the life she wants, and she's sensible about her reluctance to repeat that experience. She knows that attraction and compatibility aren't automatically the same thing, even if she sometimes forgets this when Dean's standing in front of her.


I also liked that Kennedy allows her female characters to have sexual desires without turning those desires into moral failings. Allie is neither punished for enjoying sex nor expected to justify it through an immediate declaration of love. Considering how often romance fiction still manages to attach different standards of behaviour to men and women, that's worth noting.


There is, however, an extraordinary amount of sex in this novel.


Now, I have absolutely no objection to explicit romance, provided it serves the characters and the relationship. But I did reach a point with The Score where I wanted Dean and Allie to put their clothes back on and have a proper conversation. Their physical chemistry is established so emphatically that I felt Kennedy was relying on it to do work that more substantial emotional development might have accomplished.


And this, I think, is where my experience of the book began to differ from my enjoyment of its predecessors.


The attraction between Dean and Allie is entirely believable. Their conversations are often funny, and they're pleasantly well matched when it comes to challenging one another. What I found less convincing was the pace at which that attraction develops into a relationship with genuine emotional depth. I wanted more opportunities to understand why these two people, beyond their obvious sexual compatibility, had become so important to each other.


Dean's characterisation was a little uneven for me as well. His privilege is so extensive that it sometimes makes his difficulties harder to take seriously, although Kennedy does acknowledge that a life free from financial anxiety isn't necessarily a life free from emotional uncertainty. He's been encouraged to follow a particular professional path, and his eventual recognition that he might want something different provides one of the novel's more satisfying developments.


I actually found his growing interest in coaching and working with children more compelling than several of the romantic scenes. There's an unexpected gentleness to Dean in those moments, and the pleasure he takes in helping young players reveals something that his endless flirtation can't. For maybe the first time, we see him becoming interested in something that has very little to do with his own gratification.


It's a lovely direction for the character, and I would've enjoyed seeing Kennedy spend even more time exploring it.


The novel also makes a dramatic shift in tone during its final stages, introducing a devastating loss that forces Dean to confront grief in a way he's never experienced before. A close friend's sudden death in a car accident leads to a period of serious emotional deterioration, including heavy drinking, drug use and destructive behaviour.


I understood what Kennedy was attempting here. Dean's previously uncomplicated existence is interrupted by something money, charm and intelligence can't fix. His instinct is to escape the pain rather than endure it, and his treatment of Allie becomes more hurtful as he struggles.


The problem for me wasn't the introduction of grief. It was the amount of space the novel allowed that grief to occupy.


The circumstances are genuinely distressing, and Dean's response includes behaviour serious enough to warrant more sustained examination. But the story moves towards reconciliation with a speed that left me feeling some of the emotional consequences had been tidied away too conveniently. I wasn't entirely persuaded that the relationship had been given sufficient time to recover from what happened, or that Dean's personal growth had been explored as thoroughly as the situation deserved.


Grief's rarely considerate enough to fit within the remaining chapters of a romance novel, and this particular development deserved a little more breathing room.



There are also several matters readers may prefer to know about before picking up The Score. Alongside its frequent and fairly graphic sexual content and strong language, the novel includes alcohol and recreational drug use, including a period of substance misuse following bereavement. There is a fatal car accident, intense grief, references to cancer and parental death, and the ongoing reality of a parent living with multiple sclerosis. Emotional manipulation and controlling behaviour feature in Allie's previous relationship, while depression and threats of self-harm are discussed in connection with another character. Some sexual encounters also occur in the context of alcohol or cannabis use. None of these subjects makes the novel inappropriate by definition, but the abrupt movement from playful romance into much darker territory is something readers should be aware of.





What kept The Score enjoyable for me was Kennedy's humour. She writes the absurdities of young adulthood extremely well, and there are exchanges between the hockey players that made me laugh aloud. The friendships are one of the series' strongest elements. These men tease one another mercilessly, frequently behave like overgrown schoolboys and nevertheless demonstrate genuine affection when it matters.


I also liked that Dean's eventual choices are concerned with more than just becoming a suitable boyfriend. His decision to consider a future in teaching and coaching suggests a developing understanding of what might give his life purpose. Allie's professional ambitions are similarly important, and I liked that her romantic future isn't presented as a substitute for achieving something independently.


Those ideas give the novel more substance than its initial premise might suggest. I just wanted Kennedy to follow them further.


There's an interesting question buried in Dean's story about what happens when someone who's always been good at everything finally encounters circumstances in which talent and privilege are useless. That could have supported a much richer exploration of his personality. But, the book sometimes seems impatient to return to the romance, even when the emotional material is far more interesting.


I suspect readers who enjoy explicit romance will be more enthusiastic about The Score than I was. Dean and Allie have undeniable chemistry, the dialogue's entertaining and the story has the easy readability that's made this series so popular. I can certainly understand the affection many readers have for Dean, especially once his vulnerabilities begin to emerge.


But chemistry is only one part of what makes a fictional relationship memorable to me. I need to believe in the attachment developing beneath the attraction, and I need the emotional resolutions to feel earned. On both counts, I was left wanting a little more.



Three stars, then, which in my reading world is not a bad rating. I enjoyed much of The Score, laughed often and was invested enough in these characters to want things to work out for them. It just didn't leave me with the same sense of satisfaction as The Deal or The Mistake.


Dean Di-Laurentis turned out to have more depth than I initially gave him credit for. I just wish the novel had trusted that depth enough to let us spend a little longer discovering it.



🔎 Read this if you enjoy spicy college hockey romance with humour and emotional drama 📚 Off-Campus series by Elle Kennedy — Book 3

💭 Friends with benefits, opposites attract, forced proximity and unexpected love

👥 Hockey team friendships, complicated relationships, personal ambitions and emotional growth

🌿 Love, grief, privilege, independence, self-discovery and finding purpose

⚠️ Includes explicit sexual content, strong language, alcohol and drug misuse, death, grief, depression, references to self-harm and controlling relationships.













Book Details

The Score by Elle Kennedy

Paperback ISBN

978-0349440927 — Piatkus / Little, Brown Book Group paperback edition published in Australia on 14 November 2023.

Hardcover ISBN

978-0349447926 — Piatkus / Little, Brown Book Group limited collector's hardcover edition published in Australia in 2026.

eBook ISBN

978-0349440910 — Piatkus / Little, Brown Book Group English-language digital edition published on 14 November 2023.

Audiobook ISBN

No standard 13-digit ISBN could be reliably verified for the English-language unabridged audiobook.

Genre

Contemporary Romance; New Adult Romance; Sports Romance; College Romance; Romantic Comedy; Contemporary Fiction.

Subgenre

College Hockey Romance; Campus Romance; Friends-with-Benefits Romance; Spicy Contemporary Romance; New Adult Romantic Comedy; Emotional Sports Romance.

Tropes / Literary Threads

Friends with benefits; opposites attract; reformed playboy; commitment-phobic hero; rebound romance; forced proximity; secret relationship; unexpected love; close-knit friendships; wealthy hero; personal ambition; grief and emotional growth; finding purpose

Publisher

Piatkus / Little, Brown Book Group — Australian paperback, hardcover and eBook editions.

Series

Off-Campus Series — Book 3. Features Dean Di-Laurentis and Allie Hayes. Part of an interconnected series of college hockey romances.

Formats Available

Paperback; collector's hardcover; Kindle eBook; EPUB eBook; unabridged digital audiobook.

Audiobook Narrator

Savannah Peachwood and Andrew Eiden.

Audiobook Length

11 hours and 39 minutes — unabridged English-language audiobook narrated by Savannah Peachwood and Andrew Eiden.

Original Release Date

11 January 2016 — original English-language publication.

Page Count

384 pages — Australian Piatkus paperback ISBN 9780349440927 and collector's hardcover ISBN 9780349447926.


Where to Buy The Score by Elle Kennedy

📚 Amazon


Affiliate Disclosure

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my Amazon affiliate links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I also encourage supporting Australian booksellers such as QBD Books, independent booksellers, and self-published authors whenever possible.

Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker
Silk & Sentences | Danielle Robinson - Literary Commentator, Writer, Overthinker

Danielle Robinson is a literary critic and writer whose work explores literature through the

lens of atmosphere, memory, culture, and emotional experience.


Holding a double degree in philosophy and theology, she combines academic insight with a deeply refined aesthetic sensibility shaped by more than three decades working across the creative industries as an internationally published, multi-award-winning makeup artist, fashion stylist, and interior stager.


She reads widely and rigorously, reading and reviewing more than 200 books each year as both an ARC reader and commissioned critic. Through Silk & Sentences, Danielle approaches literature as something immersive and lived with — not simply stories to consume, but works that shape the way we think, feel, and move through the world.


She writes from her semi-rural Queensland home, where she lives with Alex, her husband of 33 years, their dogs Oscar and Paige, and an ever-growing library of books.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page