
I must confess to having a fondness for historical fiction that takes someone we think we know and reveals how little we actually understand about them. Cast Away by Francesca de Tores does exactly that with Alexander Selkirk, the Scottish sailor whose extraordinary experience of being marooned on a remote Pacific island helped inspire Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe. But, having now spent several hundred pages in Selkirk's company, I wonder if I might have been tempted to leave him there myself.
In 1704, following a disagreement aboard ship, Selkirk finds himself stranded on an uninhabited island off the coast of Chile. Armed with a few supplies, considerable practical knowledge and an inexhaustible capacity for indignation, he must figure out how to survive. Hunting goats, constructing shelter, protecting his possessions from rats and finding ways to occupy his days become the immediate concerns of a man who's spent much of his life convinced that everyone else is the problem.
And what a magnificently difficult man he is.
Selkirk is arrogant, impulsive, occasionally crude and astonishingly talented at justifying his own behaviour. He's also resourceful, intelligent, determined and occasionally very funny. De Tores makes no particular effort to soften his rougher edges, which I appreciated. Too often, historical figures are retrospectively polished until they're comfortably palatable to modern audiences. Here, we encounter a man who can demonstrate extraordinary ingenuity one moment and spectacularly poor judgement the next. His ability to survive is considerably more developed than his ability to recognise when he's being an absolute git.
What makes the novel especially interesting is the way de Tores moves between Selkirk's increasingly isolated existence and the events that brought him there. His difficult childhood, family relationships, experiences at sea and involvement in the disastrous Darien colonial venture gradually reveal a man whose troubles have rarely been entirely accidental. There's a fabulous irony in watching someone so determined to escape the interference of others discover that he's rather poor company for himself.
The historical detail is excellent, especially the practical business of survival. We see how Selkirk hunts, prepares food, fashions clothing and learns to manage an environment that offers little consideration for his comfort. These descriptions give the novel a convincing physical presence, but I did occasionally feel we'd spent quite enough time attending to the daily necessities of island life. I understand why that repetition is relevant. Solitude is repetitive, and survival is largely a matter of doing the same essential things over and over again. Nevertheless, there were stretches where I wanted the story to move forward with a little more urgency.
As Selkirk's isolation deepens, an elderly goat and a wild cat become unexpected conversational companions. This is where the novel takes a delightfully peculiar turn, introducing something approaching magical realism into an otherwise carefully researched historical narrative. I loved the absurdity of a man who's struggled so thoroughly with human relationships finding himself engaged in philosophical discussions with the local wildlife. The goat, especially, makes an entertainingly improbable moral commentator.
Yet there's considerable intelligence beneath the humour. Whether these conversations are products of loneliness, manifestations of Selkirk's conscience or something we're simply invited to accept, they allow de Tores to examine guilt, responsibility and the stories people tell themselves to avoid uncomfortable truths. I wasn't entirely convinced that every aspect of this device needed quite so much explanation. Sometimes the strangeness was interesting enough to stand on its own, and I would've preferred the author to trust us a little more with the ambiguity.
Religion also plays an intriguing role, particularly through Selkirk's relationship with his Bible. His engagement with scripture is irreverent, argumentative and increasingly personal, reflecting his struggle to reconcile inherited religious beliefs with his own moral failings. I really enjoyed the way he rearranges biblical language into something resembling erasure poetry. It adds another dimension to the novel's preoccupation with interpretation, as Selkirk attempts to make sense of both the words before him and the life he's lived.
I found myself thinking quite a lot about the distinction between regret and accountability. Selkirk is certainly capable of regretting the circumstances in which he finds himself, but recognising his own contribution to them is another matter entirely. His predicament becomes an extended exercise in self-examination, whether he welcomes it or not. De Tores never makes the process tidy, and I think the novel is better for that. Personal growth is rarely as satisfying or as permanent as fiction sometimes suggests.

There are some confronting elements worth mentioning. Selkirk's survival involves the hunting, killing and butchering of animals, alongside fairly earthy descriptions of bodily functions, illness and physical discomfort. There are also crude sexual references, alcohol misuse and historical violence. More significantly, the psychological effects of prolonged isolation, loneliness, despair and religious guilt become increasingly important to the story. None of this feels gratuitous to me, but readers particularly sensitive to animal harm or psychological distress may wish to approach it with some awareness.

My reservations are mostly concerned with the pacing and the occasional tendency to explain ideas that have already been communicated effectively through the storytelling. Selkirk's difficult personality is entirely intentional and, for the most part, one of the novel's strengths. Even so, spending so much time inside his head can be exhausting. I also think the philosophical conversations occasionally become a little more prominent than the narrative needs. I enjoyed what de Tores was exploring, but there were moments when I became more conscious of the author's intentions than of the character himself.
Despite some flaws, there’s still a lot to admire. The writing is confident, the historical world feels lived in, and the humour prevents the novel's darker preoccupations from becoming oppressive. I appreciated that de Tores resists turning Selkirk's ordeal into a sentimental celebration of human resilience. Surviving something extraordinary doesn't necessarily make someone extraordinary in every other respect, and acquiring self-knowledge doesn't guarantee that we'll act upon it.
Completing Cast Away deepened my appreciation for the complex man behind one of literature’s most enduring survival tales. It's a clever, unusual and occasionally exasperating novel, much like its protagonist, and one that rewards readers who enjoy historical fiction with a substantial psychological and philosophical dimension.

A very good novel with a few elements that didn't entirely work for me, but one whose intelligence, wit and wonderfully disagreeable central character made the journey worthwhile. I can't say I'd have enjoyed being stranded with Alexander Selkirk, but I was rather glad to have met him.

🔎 Read this if you enjoy intelligent historical fiction with survival adventure, dark humour and psychological depth
📚 Cast Away by Francesca de Tores — Standalone historical novel
💭 Desert island survival, flawed protagonist, forced isolation, self-discovery and redemption
👥 Complicated family relationships, unlikely animal companions, personal conflict and moral accountability
🌿 Loneliness, resilience, identity, guilt, forgiveness, faith and human nature
⚠️ Includes animal hunting and butchering, strong language, crude sexual references, alcohol misuse, historical violence, illness and psychological distress.

Book Details
Cast Away by Francesca De Tores
Paperback ISBN
978-1526661449 — Bloomsbury Circus / Bloomsbury Publishing Australian paperback edition published on 28 April 2026.
Hardcover ISBN
978-1526661395 — Bloomsbury Circus / Bloomsbury Publishing hardcover edition published on 29 September 2026.
eBook ISBN
978-1526661401 — Bloomsbury Circus / Bloomsbury Publishing English-language digital edition published on 21 May 2026.
Audiobook ISBN
978-1526661425 — Bloomsbury Circus / Bloomsbury Publishing unabridged English-language digital audiobook published on 21 May 2026.
Genre
Historical Fiction; Literary Fiction; Adventure Fiction; Survival Fiction; Biographical Fiction; Psychological Fiction.
Subgenre
Maritime Historical Fiction; Historical Survival Adventure; Literary Historical Adventure; Psychological Survival Fiction; Eighteenth-Century Historical Fiction; Philosophical Historical Fiction.
Tropes / Literary Threads
Desert island survival; marooned sailor; flawed antihero; man versus nature; man versus self; forced isolation; unreliable narrator; unlikely animal companions; talking animals; magical realism; complicated family relationships; troubled past; moral reckoning.
Publisher
Bloomsbury Circus / Bloomsbury Publishing — Australian paperback, hardcover, eBook and audiobook editions.
Series
Standalone historical novel. A fictional reimagining of the experiences of Alexander Selkirk, the Scottish sailor whose survival inspired Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe.
Formats Available
Paperback; hardcover; Kindle eBook; EPUB eBook; unabridged digital audiobook.
Audiobook Narrator
Thoren Ferguson.
Audiobook Length
14 hours and 8 minutes — unabridged English-language audiobook narrated by Thoren Ferguson.
Original Release Date
28 April 2026 — Australian paperback publication. The Bloomsbury digital editions were released on 21 May 2026.
Page Count
336 pages — Bloomsbury Circus Australian paperback ISBN 9781526661449 and hardcover ISBN 9781526661395.
Where to Buy Cast Away by Francesca De Tores
📚 Amazon
Affiliate Disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my Amazon affiliate links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I also encourage supporting Australian booksellers such as QBD Books, independent booksellers, and self-published authors whenever possible.

Danielle Robinson is a literary critic and writer whose work explores literature through the
lens of atmosphere, memory, culture, and emotional experience.

Holding a double degree in philosophy and theology, she combines academic insight with a deeply refined aesthetic sensibility shaped by more than three decades working across the creative industries as an internationally published, multi-award-winning makeup artist, fashion stylist, and interior stager.
She reads widely and rigorously, reading and reviewing more than 200 books each year as both an ARC reader and commissioned critic. Through Silk & Sentences, Danielle approaches literature as something immersive and lived with — not simply stories to consume, but works that shape the way we think, feel, and move through the world.
She writes from her semi-rural Queensland home, where she lives with Alex, her husband of 33 years, their dogs Oscar and Paige, and an ever-growing library of books.




Comments