
I really wanted to enjoy Showtime! by Judy Nunn, after really loving Pilbara. The premise sounded wonderful: a sweeping Australian historical saga following two families through the colourful and often chaotic world of live theatre, beginning in the 1880s and continuing into the First World War. I love historical fiction that introduces me to a part of Australia's past I know relatively little about, and the early days of our entertainment industry seemed a particularly promising subject. Unfortunately, despite the fascinating setting and some genuinely interesting historical detail, I struggled to stay engaged with this one.
The story begins with the Worthing family, who arrive in Melbourne from England hoping to build a future in the entertainment business. Brothers Will and Max, along with their wives Mabel and Gertie, bring an assortment of theatrical talents to a country where live performance is becoming increasingly popular. Their ambitions eventually bring them into contact with Carlo and Rube, two enterprising young men with their own ideas about making a success of show business. From there, Nunn follows the intertwined fortunes of these performers and their families across several decades of professional triumphs, rivalries, romantic entanglements and personal tragedies.
There's certainly plenty of material to work with, and I can appreciate the considerable research that must have gone into recreating this period. The travelling theatrical companies, variety performances and developing entertainment industry provide some lovely glimpses into a world that's largely disappeared. Nunn's own background as an actress is evident in her familiarity with the business of performing, and I liked learning about the practicalities of making a living on the stage before cinema became the dominant form of popular entertainment.
My difficulty was that I often found the history considerably more interesting than the people inhabiting it. There are a lot of characters to keep track of, and while I understand the appeal of a multigenerational saga, I never developed the sort of attachment that makes me eager to return to a book. I could follow their successes and disappointments perfectly well, but I rarely felt especially invested in what happened to them. After several hundred pages, that's a rather unfortunate position to find yourself in.
The pacing didn't help. I found the opening very slow, and even once the various relationships and professional rivalries were established, the story seemed to wander rather than build towards anything especially compelling. Historical events, business developments and family complications arrive in steady succession, yet the narrative rarely generated the momentum I was hoping for. I don't mind a long novel. In fact, I generally enjoy having the opportunity to settle into a substantial story, provided the characters and writing give me a reason to stay. Here, the length increasingly felt like something I was negotiating rather than enjoying.
I also struggled with some of the character motivations, especially the prolonged bitterness involving Will, Rosie and Carlo. Jealousy, resentment and revenge can make for wonderful fiction when the emotional foundations are convincing, but I wasn't always persuaded that the intensity of these grievances was warranted. Their hostility continues to influence relationships and decisions over an extraordinary length of time, and I found myself growing impatient with it. I wanted a little more psychological complexity and rather less manufactured drama.
Rosie, especially, could have been a really interesting character. The world of theatrical performance offers considerable scope for exploring ambition, female independence and the limitations imposed upon women of the period. Instead, I found her destructive behaviour more exhausting than intriguing. I don't need fictional characters to be pleasant, or even especially likeable, but I do need to believe in them. Too often, the characters here seemed to behave according to the requirements of the plot rather than any deeper understanding of who they were.

As the story progresses, Nunn introduces significant events in Australian history, including Federation, the Sydney plague outbreak and eventually the First World War. These developments bring darker subject matter into the novel, including epidemic disease, death, bereavement, family tragedy and wartime violence. Readers sensitive to those subjects should be aware that the later sections move quite some distance from the comparatively lively theatrical atmosphere of the beginning.
Interestingly, I found portions of the later historical material more engaging than much of what preceded them, although this created another problem for me. By the time the war became a major part of the story, I felt I was reading a different novel from the one I'd originally picked up. The theatrical setting had been its greatest attraction, and I would have preferred a more sustained exploration of that world rather than such an expansive account of Australian history. The amount of ground covered is impressive, but I wasn't convinced that every diversion strengthened the storytelling.
I also found the overall structure uneven. The novel spends an enormous amount of time establishing people, relationships and historical circumstances, yet some of the eventual resolutions felt comparatively hurried. After investing so much reading time in these families, I wanted the conclusion to carry more emotional weight than it did. Perhaps I would have felt differently had I connected more strongly with the characters along the way, but the ending didn't change my overall impression.
What makes this disappointing is that I can see how much potential there was in the premise. The early Australian theatre scene is a terrific setting for a novel, especially when explored by someone who understands the profession from the inside. There are interesting questions here about artistic ambition, commercial success, loyalty, reputation and the sacrifices people make in pursuit of recognition. I simply wished those ideas had been explored through a more tightly constructed story and a smaller number of more fully realised characters.

I know Judy Nunn has a devoted readership, and I can understand why readers who enjoy detailed historical sagas might find a great deal to appreciate in Showtime!. The historical research is extensive, the setting is distinctive and there's an obvious affection for the theatrical world being depicted. For me, though, those strengths weren't enough to overcome the slow pacing, crowded narrative and characters I struggled to care about.
Two stars may seem a little harsh for a novel with so much work behind it, but I can only rate the experience I actually had. I finished Showtime! feeling that I'd learned quite a bit about Australian theatrical history without having particularly enjoyed the journey. I wanted to be swept up in the excitement of the stage and the lives of the people who made it their world. Instead, I spent too much time wishing the story would get on with it.
An interesting piece of historical research, certainly, but not one of my more enjoyable reading experiences.

🔎 Read this if you enjoy sweeping Australian historical fiction with theatrical ambition and family drama
📚 Standalone historical novels by Judy Nunn
💭 Travelling performers, vaudeville theatre, family rivalries and a changing Australia
👥 Multigenerational saga, complicated relationships, jealousy, betrayal and revenge
🌿 Ambition, loyalty, artistic success, family legacy, identity and resilience
⚠️ Includes wartime violence, death, grief, family tragedy, epidemic disease, emotional manipulation and destructive relationships.

Book Details
Showtime! by Judy Nunn
Paperback ISBN
978-1761042546 — Penguin Australia paperback edition published on 29 November 2022.
Hardcover ISBN
No standard English-language hardcover edition or ISBN could be reliably verified.
eBook ISBN
978-1761042553 — Random House Australia digital edition published on 28 September 2021.
Audiobook ISBN
978-1761045486 — Penguin Random House Australia Audio unabridged English-language digital audiobook published on 28 September 2021.
Genre
Historical Fiction; Australian Fiction; Family Saga; Literary Fiction; Historical Drama; Contemporary Australian Literature.
Subgenre
Australian Colonial Historical Fiction; Multigenerational Family Saga; Theatrical Historical Fiction; Victorian-Era Historical Fiction; Australian Wartime Fiction; Historical Family Drama; Showbusiness Fiction.
Tropes / Literary Threads
Rags to riches; travelling performers; theatrical rivalry; family ambition; found family; complicated family relationships; artistic ambition versus commercial success; forbidden romance; jealousy and betrayal; revenge and resentment; generational conflict
Publisher
Penguin / Penguin Random House Australia — paperback editions.
Series
Standalone historical novel; no series designation.
Formats Available
Trade paperback; paperback; Kindle eBook; EPUB eBook; unabridged digital audiobook. No standard hardcover edition could be reliably verified.
Audiobook Narrator
John Derum and Judy Nunn.
Audiobook Length 19 hours and 9 minutes — unabridged English-language audiobook narrated by John Derum and Judy Nunn.
Original Release Date
28 September 2021 — original Australian publication.
Page Count
528 pages — Australian Penguin paperback ISBN 9781761042546 and original trade paperback edition.
Where to Buy Showtime! by Judy Nunn
📚 Amazon
Affiliate Disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through my Amazon affiliate links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. I also encourage supporting Australian booksellers such as QBD Books, independent booksellers, and self-published authors whenever possible.

Danielle Robinson is a literary critic and writer whose work explores literature through the
lens of atmosphere, memory, culture, and emotional experience.

Holding a double degree in philosophy and theology, she combines academic insight with a deeply refined aesthetic sensibility shaped by more than three decades working across the creative industries as an internationally published, multi-award-winning makeup artist, fashion stylist, and interior stager.
She reads widely and rigorously, reading and reviewing more than 200 books each year as both an ARC reader and commissioned critic. Through Silk & Sentences, Danielle approaches literature as something immersive and lived with — not simply stories to consume, but works that shape the way we think, feel, and move through the world.
She writes from her semi-rural Queensland home, where she lives with Alex, her husband of 33 years, their dogs Oscar and Paige, and an ever-growing library of books.




Comments